8/6/14 Assembly

Today was spent assembling the Modular Beast.  Turns out, the tensioner pin holes are too small.  As a result, we had to resort to super glue and fishing line.  Now I know why we never used fishing line before.  On the bright side, the knuckles snap to the RIT Arm palm very well.  Almost too well.  They don't acutally come off.  But that's okay with me, they shouldn't need to.  After adjusting the thumb bend I thought I fixed and widening the finger slots, we started printing a new one.  The RIT Arm should be done by tomorrow, and then we should be ready for the presentation.

Knuckles, fitting to the palm.

Evidence of the knuckles delaminating because the are not flexible.

To fix the delamination of the knuckles, I decided to add a small slot in the center similar to the way the pins are made.  This way the knuckle is flexible enough to not crack when it is attached. This will hopefully be the final change and as we head into our last day we hope to have everything assembled and ready to go.

That's all for today!

Alex + Sam

8/4/14 Final Week Begins

As we enter the final week of this program progress begins to slow. Today we sent off our poster to be printed and if I may say so myself it looks pretty good! At this point we have basically made all of the necessary modifications to the RIT arm and modular beast. We can only work as fast as the printers which unfortunately take hours per print. Today, Sam and Frankie came up with a plan to notch the fingers for the RIT arm so they will work in the new splayed configuration. Further testing will be done on this tomorrow. I (Alex) cleaned up the modular beast model a bit and helped John laser cut some parts for a lamp based on a Thingiverse design.

Today from 4pm-8pm Frankie hosted a group of 11 high school level women engineers and they were planning on assembling John's solar lamps and sending them to less fortunate children in Guatemala. Due to this class and the slow pace of printing, we left the lab a bit early today.

Well that's all for today, hopefully soon we will have all of the parts printed and uploaded to Thingiverse!

Alex + Sam

8/1/14 Finishing Up Drawing and Finishing Poster

Today we made all of the final changes to both the RIT arm and the modular beast so we can begin printing and assembling the models for next week. These parts are fairly large so printing takes quite awhile. In our downtime between prints, work continued on our poster. Because our poster is due on Monday we won't be able to include any actual pictures of these devices, instead we assembled and took screenshots of them in Inventor/Rhino.

One of the modular beast design photos included on our poster.

Although not as exciting as usual, today was a necessary day and we are right on track with completing everything by next Friday for our presentation.

Alex + Sam

7/31/14 Fingers & Phalanges and Finishing Up Modular Beast

Today was a pretty productive day.  Frankie's back and because he gave me the files to his fingers, I was able to make progress on the arm today.  I beefed up the tricep cuff with some ribs to support it and tweaked the palm to fit Frankie's phalanges.  Through Inventor's assembly mode, I was able to look at how the fingers would fit to the palm and was able to adjust the knuckles accordingly.  Here's a shot of how it should look.

Now that I know they fit, the next thing to do is find a way to connect the phalanges to the palm.  I would like to do it without cutting them in half and screwing them together.  Feel free to message me on e-NABLE if you have any ideas about that.  I'll talk to Frankie tomorrow to see if he has any ideas as well.  On the bright side,  I won't have to do any work when it comes to putting pins in the fingers, because Frankie already did it. 

Tomorrow is a short day, so I plan on taking some quality pictures of the RIT Arm and Modular Beast.  I will probably end up ordering some springs for the variable grip too.

Work continued on the modular beast today, all of the parts finally printed! After talking to Frankie and going over the e-NABLE feedback about our compression fit design I decided to adapt a dovetail design instead. This design is still very simple to print (minimal supports needed) and it works very well.

The new dovetail design.

The Modular Beast in the real world!

After putting everything together Frankie pointed out that the gauntlet seems to be scaled smaller than the rest of the hand. This is a fairly quick fix and hopefully after tomorrow I will have a larger gauntlet to print. I also started printing Sam's bike attachment, that should be done printing tomorrow.

Overall today was another busy and productive day!

Alex + Sam

7/30/14 Printing Continued and Publishing Modular Tensioner

Printing continued.  Printing issues continued.  The day was spent managing the printers as we printed parts for the modular hand and arm.  Not much to say about that.  I spent some time drawing up a claw to demonstrate with the modular beast. The claw intended to be an attachment for biking.  In the end, it turned out to be quite terrifying.

See what I mean?  The lower claw closest to the palm is meant to support the biker leaning up against the bike handle bar. The longer front claw is supposed to wrap around the brake handles.  When the biker wants to stop, he or she pulls the claw towards themselves to pull the brake.  That's the plan at least.  I know this will be a pain to print though.  And it might not be strong enough.  However, if it doesn't work, it can still be used for demonstration at our presentation.  

As with Sam I (Alex) spent most of my day printing parts for the modular beast. In between prints I redesigned the mid gauntlet (it looks much better now and should hopefully be stronger) and published the completed modular tensioner block to e-NABLE. 

The compression fit gauntlet and tensioner block published on e-NABLE.

Hopefully the last modular gauntlet design!

The modular tensioner block wasn't met very well by the e-NABLE community who don't like to rely on compression fittings. I kind of agree with them because every printer is setup/calibrated differently but these types of designs are very strong and easy to print (no supports needed). Either way I think I'm going to stick with this design for the presentation.

We are trying to get all of our design work done this week so we can spend all of next week printing/assembling and getting ready to present our poster. This has been and will continue to be a very busy week but time flies when you are having fun!

Alex + Sam

7/29/14 Printing Parts and Starting Poster

While we wait for new parts to print, Alex and I have done a bit of preparation for the final symposium. First, I did some work on the final designs for the RIT Arm.  As it turns out, my idea of cutting material cost on the forearm cuff was a huge waste of time. I thought it would be a good idea to save time and material by cutting holes in the cup.  Turns out, it takes more plastic to print the supports with holes than it did without the holes.  Talk about a waste of time.

The original forearm cup took about 5 hours to print and only used 69 grams of ABS.
The "material saving" version takes 77 grams and 2 extra hours.

 After putting the finishing touches on the RIT Arm redesign, I began work on the poster.  This included typing the intro for each of our projects.  We plan to have a section about the e-NABLE community and it's purpose, as well as sections for the work we did on the RIT Arm and Modular Beast.  We hope to show our progress and spread the word about e-NABLE at the same time.

While Sam was working on the poster I (Alex) began printing parts for the modular beast. I finally got the tolerance on the tensioner block to fit perfectly! I also squared off the tensioner pin holders on the gauntlet that I talked about yesterday. After doing this I added some extra support to the gauntlet so the tensioner block doesn't appear to be "floating". My modified modular gauntlet was printed today but it turned out to be too flimsy so I added some extra material. It doesn't look the greatest but that can always be changed later.

The new gauntlet with extra support for the tensioner block and square tensioner pin holders.

The new mid gauntlet, not great looking but hopefully functional.

That's all for today.

Alex + Sam

7/28/14 Finish of Arm Editing and Modular Hand

Today, I (Sam) believe I finally completed the editing of the RIT Arm.  Thank god.  I'll go over them with Alex to see what else needs to be done, but I think it's good for now.  I think we should start printing it in blue or teal to be able to tell the difference between our arm and the RIT Arm.  Then we can use that in our presentation.

The palm was finished today.  The fingers are splayed and staggered, which will be paired with variable grip to increase strength.  Work was done to the tubes inside the palm to make stringing easier and make movement lag less.  A bar drawn in the knuckle joints to allow for a finger to close around it.  The file also allows for changing the bars into hole for pins.  Here's a picture of the progress.

While Sam was hard at work on the the RIT arm, I (Alex) continued work on the Modular Beast. Today I adapted the tensioner block connecting design I talked about yesterday to the gauntlet. I am still having a few problems getting the tolerance correct, but that should be a quick fix. Unfortunately, I printed the entire gauntlet before realizing that the tensioner rests were still set up for the old hex style tensioners. This is just a minor detail so it's not worth reprinting, but I will have to change that for tomorrow.

Yesterday's design adapted for the gauntlet.

Today, I also added slots to our mid gauntlet, which should allow for our new tensioner block to be easily attached and detached without restringing. This is a very minor detail but will be extremely important when assembling this hand.

A small detail but extremely important.

On another note, we began working on our UR@UWM poster today. John made a similar poster, which now hangs outside the DCRL, and he offered to share his files so we can match it as best we can. We have our layout set and now it's just a matter of sitting down and actually doing the poster.

That's all for today, overall it was a very productive one!

Alex + Sam

7/24/14 New Game Plan, Another Modular Tensioner Design

Today Alex and I came up with new goals to have done by the time this program ends.  First, we should have a working model of the Modular Beast and at least one attachment for it.  For now, that is primarily Alex's job.  Our next goal is to have a printed model of our version of the RIT Derek Arm.  We plan on applying splayed fingers and variable grip to it to make it more effective.

I looked on e-NABLE for ideas about variable grip.  The two best options I found were made by David Orgeman and Steve Wood.

Steve Wood tensioner balancing design

 I decided not to do this one because the strings get bunched together and tangled inside the tubing.  I'm afraid this would cause more problems than it is worth.

Orgeman spring design

Instead I have decided to adapt the above Orgeman design. By adding springs to the existing tensioner variable grip is achieved in a very consistent and simple manner. This has the down side of requiring non-printed springs but we believe that the benefits outweigh the cost.

As with yesterday I (Alex) continued to try and find a way to make the modular tensioner work. As I feared, the pins had a tough time printing and when I printed with PLA instead of ABS plastic they had nowhere near the flexibility required. After talking to Frankie about this problem we decided to adopt a design inspired by the bearing belt guide from a RepRap 3D printer.

My new modular tensioner design

This friction fit design is very simple and easy to print while still remaining strong. A few modifications will need to be made to prevent the tensioner assembly from rotating but overall I really think this could be the final design.

That's all for today, we have a field trip with our other undergrad research students tomorrow so we won't have anything new to post. See you next week!

Alex + Sam

7/23/14 RIT Arm Editing and Printing Pins

I spent today in Inventor with the Derek Arm.  Improvements were made in all the pieces except the fingers and knuckles.  First, I fixed up the trouble with the thumb tube in the palm by making the curve less extreme.  All it took was some quick dragging of control points.  Now the string should be able to tread through with less resistance.  Hopefully this helps with the lag in the closing of the thumb.  Next, I made the tensioners square.  After that, I edited the gauntlet to accept the new shape.  Here are some screenshots.

I put some holes through the gauntlet to reduce the amount of material used as well.  It should hold up just as well as it did with all the excess material.  

I decided to do the same for the forearm cuff, however, I'm not sure how it will turn out.  

I'm hoping to do a bit more editing with the arm tomorrow.  Then, I plan on printing it to show what Alex and I have done to improve it.  However, I don't think putting a few holes in it would make it worth printing another arm.  

I'll have to do more work on improving the overall functionality of the arm.  While I think it works fine now, we should do some brainstorming to see if there's anyway to make it better.  For example, the shape of the palm works, but it doesn't seem right to me.  I think we should come up with a better shape for it. We should also consider ways we can use the palm to get better grip out of the hand.  Maybe we can use the space inside the palm or pipe to apply the variable grip mechanisms.  Maybe the palm itself can slightly to better grip the object.  Maybe adding another thumb on the other side would help grip.  

I would like to make the first pair and second pair of fingers closing time be slightly staggered, splayed, and closer together as well.  In order to do this and make it effective, I think the arm needs variable grip. I'll come up with some sketches for that tomorrow hopefully.

While Sam was working in Inventor I spent my day in Rhino trying to sort out our modular tensioner problems. After searching around the web for awhile I decided to try a snap pin design similar to the pins used in the Cyborg Beast fingers. I already had one of these pins drawn up from when I was working with the Cyborg Beast earlier so all it took was some clever extruding and scaling.

My new pin design (shown in green)

Printing pins vertically like I have drawn above can sometimes be problematic but hopefully with some supports the print will turn out okay. Further testing on this will be conducted tomorrow.

Well that's all for today!

Alex + Sam

7/22/14 Inventor, Fusion 360, Modular Tensioner Problems

We finally got around to installing Inventor today!  I spent the day re-familiarizing myself with the Inventor while Alex continued work on our modular tensioner idea.  After fixing, printing, and refixing, we determined that the prongs are not flexible enough to be used here.  If they were longer, it might work, but that would significantly increase the size of the tensioner housing.  Tomorrow we shall discuss other solutions.

A example of how the prongs continue to break.

Meanwhile, I began work on editing the RIT Derek Arm.  So far I removed material from the Triceps Cuff to make it a bit cheaper (less material = less $$$).  Tomorrow I will probably do the same with the forearm cup.

Today we also published our modular tensioner idea to the e-NABLE community which received a very positive reaction. I (Alex) spent the majority of my day trying to come up with ways of beefing up these clips while maintaining flexibility but in the end I believe we will have to find some other type of clip.

One of several concepts I drew up today to try and beef up the prongs (sadly this didn't work)

The e-NABLE community is pushing hard for all designers to use a single program, Autodesk Fusion 360, so we spent some of our day installing and playing with this program. Fusion 360 is cloud based so it didn't run nearly as smooth as Rhino does. This combined with a more constraining (as opposed to the more free flow Rhino gives you) led to a negative reaction towards Fusion 360. The program appears to be very powerful but I just don't know if we will be able to break our Rhino habits and get into using it.

Well that's all for today!

Alex + Sam

7/21/14 Frankie's Day Off

Frankie isn't here today, so Alex and I are working mostly alone.  I have to admit, we got less done without him.  After spending an hour or so working out the size issues with the mid gauntlet and tensioner housing, I wasn't sure what else to do.  Alex and I decided to start work on redesigning the RIT Arm, but we realized we didn't know enough about Rhino to be able to do anything significant in a reasonable amount of time.  Because most of the original files for the Arm are Inventor files, I would love to begin editing the Arm in Inventor, but we are still waiting for the licence to be renewed.  After that, the real progress can begin.  We found ways to stay busy today, but we accomplished less than I would have liked.

The new and improved Mid Gauntlet with some sizing issues that were ironed out.

7/18/14 Modular Hand Additions

After posting our video about the modular hand last night, we received feedback about how to easily replace the strings.  We thought of this roadblock a while ago, but we decided it was time to confront the problem.  We decided to use the same snap fittings to be able to move the entire 'tuning block' from hand to hand.  Here's a prototype we drew up and are in the process of printing.

Here's the piece we printed today.

This part houses the tensioners.  The rectangles act as the female part of the link.  The male parts come out of the gauntlet.  This set up will keep the fitting from going inside the gauntlet and interfering with the wearers arm underneath.

The mid gauntlet finished printing today as well.  However, the female half of  the fitting is slightly to small for the male half.  And the walls of it are too thin.  With some tweaking, the mid gauntlet should be ready to go.

Someone mentioned the durability of these fittings.  Right now we are printing the prototypes in ABS, however, the male part isn't as flexible as we hoped.  To overcome this, we plan on printing in nylon to get more flexibility and durability.

That's all we have for today.  Join us next week when we finish the Modular Hand and maybe start another project!

Sam and Alex

7/17/14 RIT Arm Complete and Durability Tests!

Today was spent doing the final stringing and tensioning of the RIT Arm.  Overall, the arm works pretty well.  The only part that still sticks is the thumb.  It's sanded well, so I figure the thicker string is having trouble moving around the sharp curve in the thumb tube.  We'll have to work that out in the redesign.  We also changed the elastic bands of a few fingers to get them to the same tension of the rest of the fingers.  Here are a few pictures of our completed RIT Arm.

After finishing off the arm, we decided to do durability tests on the Cyborg Beast.  This included dropping the hand onto concrete from one story, three stories, and down a long stairwell several times.  The hand did very well in the drop test.  The only damage was in the cracked rails on the gauntlet that hold the Velcro in place. We aren't surprised they broke because the rails were very thin.  A few small modifications could beef it up.  Otherwise, the hand only suffered scuffs and a loose tensioner occasionally popped out.

After the drop test, we simulated a harsh environment by sandblasting the hand.  Sand got in all the joints and gummed up the entire system.  This was expected.  Any joint system would get stuck, no matter what it was made of.  Rinsing off the sand got the joints mostly unstuck.  At the same time, we learned that the Velcro straps work when wet.

We also printed the palm for the Modular Gauntlet and a test block.  Surprisingly, the snap fit actually worked!  I was expecting the prongs to break of the ABS to be too rigid but it worked great!  We posted a video about it to e-NABLE (https://plus.google.com/communities/102497715636887179986) and will eventually apply the slots to our mid gauntlet!  Yay we're contributing!

That's all for today!

Alex + Sam

7/16/14 RIT Arm Stringing, Handomatic

The RIT fingers finally printed!  We started off the day by sanding the fingers.  Then, we assembled the hand.  Turns out the thumb sticks because of the mess up with the knuckles.  We will probably reprint in.  In order to string the elastic bands, we mocked up and printed 10 small beads (printed in red) to anchor the strings.  Tying the knots was a pain because we didn't know how tight it needed to be, however, we learned it was fine.

Stringing of the elastic bands

Stringing the white strings was much more difficult.  Because the hand was designed for fishing line, the thicker string wouldn't easily go through the holes in the knuckles and palm.  First, we tried using a thin copper wire to pull the string through.  Even the copper wire was too thick for the holes, so we used a light weight fishing line to pull the string through.  This worked beautifully...until we reached the thumb.  As it turns out, the hole that feeds the string from the thumb to the palm has a sharp turn in it.  The string would get caught on the corner, then the line would snap trying to pull it through.  After quite a bit of work and jimmying of the string, it was finally pulled through.

The RIT hand after pulling all 5 strings through the fingers (the strings are white above)

The tensioners printed!

As a result of our struggles stringing the RIT hand, we reached several valuable conclusions about stuff we definitely need to change.

1.  Replace Chicago screws with 3D printed pins

2.  Use less material by making the pieces more "wireframed" (the tricep mount and elbow socket don't need to be solid pieces)

3.  Round the curve in the string tunnel from the thumb to the palm as discussed above

4.  Get rid of beads by adding holes in the palm to tie the elastic bands through (similar to Cyborg Beast design)

5.  Add silicone sleeve around elbow socket

6.  (I'm sure we'll find more problems)

We weren't able to complete assembly today but tomorrow we should be able to string up the tensioners and have a completed arm.

While talking to Frankie today I (Alex) found out that there is web based application created by the e-NABLE community known as Handomatic that aims to allow people to use a web interface to create hand models for printing. This application is still in development but I plan to investigate and possibly contribute code to this project.

Handomatic which is still in development

Hopefully tomorrow we will be able to finish the RIT arm and get back to working on more Cyborg Beast designs, but that's all for today!

Alex + Sam

7/15/14 Modular Hand Issues

Today was spent on Rhino, trying to find a good way to apply the snap fit design to the existing model of the Cyborg Beast.  We printed a prototype to see how well the snap fit works when printed.  However, after losing track of the number of failed prints, we decided to make do with what we had.

The Intermediate Gauntlet (yellow) is supposed to clip into slots on the test block (red).  However, the left arm of the gauntlet failed to print in one piece.

From the prototype fitting, I learned that more length was needed to add flexibility to the rigid plastic.  In the Rhino model, the arm was made thinner and slightly longer.  Also, clearance space was needed in order to ensure a snug but easy to remove fit.

After this test it was decided that the peg should be part of the hand itself instead of the gauntlet.  This is because we figured it would be easier to apply the peg to existing hand models rather than needing to change current hands when adding the slots.  The slots will be permanently part of the intermediate gauntlet.
The most trouble came from leaving space for the slots on the gauntlet.  When the model is completed tomorrow, I will include a picture of it in the next update.
On the bright side, the fingers of the RIT Arm were finally printed.  All we need are the pins, then we

should be ready to assemble tomorrow.

RIT fingers being printed

While Sam worked on making these hands more modular I (Alex) spent my day trying to make these hand designs easier to print. One of the most annoying parts about assembling these hands is the long Chicago screw used to mount all four fingers to the palm. To try and fix this I am designing a 3D printed pin that will slide in to the palm and replace the long screw.

Above you can see my pin (shown in red) and the palm (shown in grey) that it will fit into

Due to my relative lack of experience with Rhino it is taking my quite some time to get this pin designed but the more I work with this program the better I am getting. After we get the RIT arm assembled (hopefully tomorrow!) I plan on putting together a formal documentation paper showcasing the printing, assembling, and potentially modification of the RIT arm.

Well that's all for today, look forward to some completed RIT arm pictures tomorrow!

Alex + Sam

7/14/14 RIT Gauntlet, Roboarm, and Printer Problems

The RIT Gauntlet was finished today.  It printed beautifully.  Cleaning out the supports was a pain, but in the end it looks good.  Once the fingers are done, it will be ready to be assembled.

Today we began the assembly of John's roboarm.  We put bearings in all the fingers, and screwed the halves of the fingers together.  However, we can't continue the assembly of this project until the motors for the fingers arrive.

Assembled fingers and unfinished palm

Due to problems with one of the Maker Bots being jammed in both extruders, we were unable to have the fingers for the RIT arm printed for the day, and we were unable to print the first test of the snap fit we decided on for the modular hand.  Here's a picture of the snap fit we plan on applying to the Cyborg Beast.

Before the printer jammed up Frankie showed both Sam and I how to use both the vinyl cutter and there 40 watt laser engraver/cutter. We printed a stack of Storm Trooper stickers and engraved a Storm Trooper on a piece of wood.

One of the stickers on my laptop!

While the printer was jammed it gave me (Alex) some time to get back into Rhino working on ways to make the current Cyborg Beast hand design easier to print. My main areas of focus are eliminating external hardware (Chicago screws) by using 3D printed pins and making parts printable without support. Support used in 3D printing adds print time and ends up getting thrown away and wasted. I haven't really gotten very far in this project but I plan to work on it heavily this week.

I plan on replacing most all Chicago screws with 3D printed pins (shown in red above)

Overall today wasn't as productive as it could have been with one of the printers being down but we still managed to make the best of our down time and learn some cool new skills!

Alex + Sam